Amish Peanut Butter Church Spread Recipe: Traditional Treat ⛪

⛪🥜 Amish Church Spread

feature amish church spread

You can take a step back in time when you make this simple, three-ingredient, authentic Amish peanut butter spread, also known as Church Spread.

This sweet peanut butter and marshmallow mixture has been a popular staple for generations in Amish communities.

Today, you’ll often find this delicious treat served at Amish restaurants, gift shops, and roadside stands.

Historically, it was traditionally enjoyed on fresh baked dinner rolls or biscuits after a church service.

It’s incredibly quick to mix up, requires absolutely no cooking, and is guaranteed to be a hit with anyone who loves a sweet, decadent spread.

A Taste of Amish Tradition 📜

While the Amish lifestyle is often associated with simplicity, this spread offers a surprisingly sweet component to their traditional gatherings.

The History of Church Spread

Gatherings: If you visit an Amish family’s home after a long church service, you are very likely to find this sweet spread alongside homemade breads and rolls.
Sweetness Factor: This recipe uses three inherently sweet ingredients (corn syrup, marshmallow creme, and peanut butter), resulting in a spread that is intentionally decadent and rich.

Unique Serving Suggestions

The Classic Way: The spread is absolute perfection on a hot dinner roll, a warm biscuit, or fresh baked toast.
The Adventurous Way: Historically, this sweet spread was used in a specific sandwich combination with pickles and bologna to keep tummies from rumbling during long church days. You might want to skip that combination, but it shows how versatile the spread can be!
Serving Tip: Because the spread is very sweet, a small amount goes a long way. Serve it in moderation, or pile it on thick if you have a true sweet tooth!

Ingredient Notes and Texture 🥣

The beauty of this recipe is that it only requires three ingredients and about five minutes of prep time.

Peanut Butter: Use creamy peanut butter for the best, smoothest texture.
Marshmallow Creme: Marshmallow Creme (also known as Marshmallow Fluff) is essential for that light, airy texture that sets this spread apart from simple peanut butter mixes.
Mixing: The only instruction is to stir all three ingredients together until the mixture is uniform and smooth. A simple spoon or spatula is all you need!

⛪🥜 Amish Peanut Butter Recipe

⏱️ Prep Time: 5 Minutes | Cook Time: None | Yield: 16 Servings

🥣 Ingredients

1 cup Light Corn Syrup 🍚
¼ cup Marshmallow Creme (Marshmallow Fluff) ☁️
½ cup Creamy Peanut Butter 🥜

🥄 Supplies

Mixing Bowl
Measuring Cup and Spoons
Spoon or Spatula (for mixing)

📝 Instructions

Combine: Add the light corn syrup, marshmallow creme, and creamy peanut butter to a mixing bowl.
Mix: Stir all three ingredients together thoroughly until the mixture is completely smooth and uniform in color and texture.
Serve: Enjoy immediately on warm bread, biscuits, or rolls! Store leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator.

Ready to Try This Nostalgic Spread? ⬇️

This traditional Amish spread is the perfect sweet condiment for your next gathering, brunch, or simple family dinner.

What will you top with your Amish spread?