• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure Policy

Mama Likes To Cook

California Orange County Food Blogger - Recipes Restaurants, Adventures & Travel

  • About
  • Recipes
    • Appetizers
    • Beverages
    • Breakfast
    • Dessert
    • Dinner
    • Lunch
    • Side Dishes
    • Snacks
    • Round Ups
  • Reviews
  • Restaurants
    • Orange County
    • Los Angeles
    • California
    • United States
    • International
  • Travel
    • Orange County
    • Los Angeles
    • California
    • United States
    • International

Christmas Food: Reindeer Nutella Sandwich Recipe

November 20, 2021 by Valerie Mitchell

Pin
Share
X
This reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe is absolutely adorable and delicious, so it is perfect to serve throughout the holiday season.This reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe is absolutely adorable and delicious, so it is perfect to serve throughout the holiday season.This reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe is absolutely adorable and delicious, so it is perfect to serve throughout the holiday season.This reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe is absolutely adorable and delicious, so it is perfect to serve throughout the holiday season.This reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe is absolutely adorable and delicious, so it is perfect to serve throughout the holiday season.

 

Easy Reindeer Sandwich

feature reindeer nutella sandwich recipe

This reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe is absolutely adorable and delicious, so it is perfect to serve throughout the holiday season.

Rudolph has pretzel ears, candy eyes and a cute red nose that is super fun. 

Of course, this sandwich also tastes amazing, since it is filled with chocolate hazelnut Nutella. 

lots of reindeer nutella sandwiches

Is this reindeer Nutella sandwich recipe good for parties?

These cute Rudolph the Red Nosed Reindeer Nutella sandwiches are great for parties and are a popular item on a buffet table. 

They can also be a fun little surprise for the family, when you are enjoying other family traditions together.

Also, it would be fun to serve them with my star cutout sandwiches. 

1 reindeer rudolph sandwich

Is it ok to make the Rudolph sandwiches ahead of time?

Yes, you can make the sandwiches ahead of time and save the last minute rush for other party prep.

If you are making ahead, store the sandwiches in an airtight container or on a platter that is covered completely with Saran Wrap (or similar). 

Keeping the air out is a must, since you don’t want the bread to dry out. 

Just be careful, so the antlers, eyes and red nose don’t come off.

nutella personalized jar

Can the Christmas sandwiches be packed in a lunch?

You can pack the reindeer sandwich in a lunch, but will need to be careful with the decorations. 

It will do the best in a bento box type lunch box, so that you can keep it protected. 

You don’t want Rudolph to get squished or lose his antlers, candy nose or candy eyes. 

ingredients for rudolph reindeer sandwiches

Can I make the reindeer sandwiches gluten free?

My sandwiches in the photos contain gluten, but you can make these sandwiches gluten-free if you’d like. 

Soft, spongy bread works best with cookie cutters, so keep that in mind when choosing a loaf. 

Nutella is naturally gluten-free. 

Is this cute recipe vegetarian or vegan?

The reindeer sandwiches are vegetarian, but mine are made with Nutella and are not vegan. 

There are vegan chocolate hazelnut spreads that are delicious, so that is an easy swap for a vegan.

2 reindeer nutella sandwiches on plate

What should I use for the red nose?

My first choice for Rudolph’s nose is a red peanut M&M candy, but you can substitute. 

A plan M&M, Red Hot or other red candy will be cute, too. 

Are These Sandwiches Just for Kids?

These Rudolph sandwiches are definitely kid friendly, since they look cute, can be eaten by hand and taste good. 

However, adults can enjoy them, too. 

If you have them out on a buffet table, there is a good chance that kids won’t be the only ones eating these fun holiday sandwiches.

rudolph reindeer sandwiches

Can Kids Help Make The Christmas Sandwiches?

Making sandwiches shaped like Rudolph is a fun activity that doesn’t involve dangerous equipment, so kids can join in and help. 

Cookie cutters are fun for kids, whether they are used for these sandwiches, cookies or Play-doh. 

No sharp knives are needed, since a table knife is all you need to spread the Nutella.

And kids will enjoy adding the antlers, eyes and red nose. 

holiday reindeer sandwiches

What to Do with The Leftover Bread?

The crust and bread that is left over after you’ve cut out the heart shaped reindeer head with a cookie cutter doesn’t have to go to waste. 

The easiest use for the bread during the holiday season is to cut it into smaller pieces and add it to whatever other bread you are using for stuffing. 

Another idea is to let it dry out and crumble it to use as bread crumbs in other recipes. 

Or your child may just want to snack on it, when they are helping you make the sandwiches.

nutella rudolph sandwich

Reindeer Nutella Sandwich Recipe

Prep time: 10 minutes
Total time: 10 minutes
Yield: 4 Servings

Ingredients

8 slices Soft White Bread
Nutella
Red Candy (M&Ms, Red Hots…)
Candy Eyes
Small Pretzel Twists

Supplies

Heart Cookie Cutter

Instructions

1) Use the heart shaped cookie cutter to cut hearts from the bread slices.

2) Spread Nutella onto half of the bread hearts, but be careful not to get it too close to the edges. Put the other bread pieces on top of the ones with Nutella on them.

3) Attach 2 pretzel “antlers” to the top of the heart sandwiches.

4) Use a dab of Nutella as “glue” to attach eyes and red noses to each sandwich.

5) Enjoy!

christmas reindeer sandwiches

More from Mama Likes To Cook 

Check out the rest of my vegetarian recipes, so you can get more great ideas for baking, cooking, blending and juicing.

Christmas Animal Recipes

  • Reindeer Oreo Pops
  • Nutella Reindeer Sandwiches
  • Reindeer Cookies
  • Polar Bear Paw Print Marshmallows for Hot Cocoa
  • Polar Bear Cookies

Holiday Party Dip

  • Hummus Wreath
  • Tzatziki Wreath
  • Wreath Cheese Platter

Holiday Party Drinks without Alcohol

  • Sparkling Lemonade Punch
  • Holiday Crock Pot Tea
  • Raspberry Sparkling Ice Cream Punch
  • Ho Ho Holiday Cherry Slush Mocktail
  • Berry Peach Punch

Nutella Recipes

  • Warm Nutella Smoothie
  • Nutella Banana Chips
  • S’mores Puff Pastry
  • Air Fryer Nutella Uncrustables Donuts
  • Pinwheels
  • Reindeer Cookies
  • Reindeer Sandwich
  • Nutella Bread Pudding

Are you ready to have some delicious fun in the kitchen?

rudolph sandwich on little plate

Pin
Share
X

Filed Under: Lunch, Recipes Tagged With: christmas, nutella, reindeer, sandwich

Previous Post: « Easy Christmas Wreath Cheese Platter Recipe
Next Post: Mocha Peppermint Smoothie Recipe with Oats »

Primary Sidebar

Follow Me

  • Bluesky
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Contact Me

Email: [email protected]

Search

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter


We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to
provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Copyright © 2025 Mama Likes To Cook. All Rights Reserved.