Picky Eater Approved! Fun & Easy Cutout Star Sandwiches 🤩
Turn lunchtime into an adventure with this adorable Cutout Star Sandwich recipe!
This playful, kid-friendly idea transforms the ordinary sandwich into an exciting treat that is sure to delight even the pickiest eaters.
It comes together in just 10 minutes of prep time using simple ingredients and a cookie cutter.
The small peek-a-boo center lets the colorful jam filling shine, making it visually appealing for all ages.
Whether you’re packing a lunchbox, setting out a festive buffet, or just aiming to make weekday lunch more fun, these star-shaped delights are the perfect, easy solution!
Why You’ll Love This Cutout Star Sandwich Recipe:
- Kid-Approved Fun: The star shape and peek-a-boo jam filling make these sandwiches visually appealing and irresistible to picky eaters. They’re perfect for encouraging kids to enjoy a healthy and delicious lunch.
- Easy & Customizable: This recipe comes together in just 10 minutes with minimal ingredients. Feel free to get creative with fillings! Add peanut butter, different jams, or even savory spreads for endless variations.
- Perfect for Parties & Lunchboxes: These star-shaped sandwiches are a delightful addition to any party platter or lunchbox. They’re easy to grab and go, making them ideal for busy mornings.
- Great for All Ages: Who says fun shapes are just for kids? Adults will appreciate the playful presentation and delicious taste of these unique sandwiches.
- Festive Twist: Looking for a festive touch for the holidays? Use red and green colored bread or festive cookie cutters to create a fun and thematic lunch option.
Kids Can Help Make The Cutout Star Sandwiches
This recipe is perfect for getting kids involved in the kitchen!
Since no sharp knives are needed, they can safely help cut out the star shapes with cookie cutters and spread the jam.
For a delicious PB&J twist, simply spread your favorite nut butter on the bread first, then add the jam and top it all off with the star-shaped bread cutout.
This ensures the vibrant jam color remains visible in the center of the sandwich.
Cute Sandwiches That Are Fun for All
Dietary restrictions are no problem either!
Opt for soft, spongy gluten-free bread that works well with cookie cutters.
To ensure the sandwiches are vegan, choose bread loaves that don’t contain dairy products (always check the label!).
Planning a party?
Make these sandwiches ahead of time and store them in an airtight container or on a covered platter to prevent drying.
And don’t toss those leftover bread scraps!
They can be chopped up for stuffing during the holidays or crumbled into breadcrumbs for future recipes.
Customization Station: Filling Swaps and Festive Twists 🌈
The beauty of this simple recipe is its flexibility!
You can easily swap ingredients to suit any picky palate or party theme.
Filling Swaps
- Classic PB&J: For the best presentation, spread your favorite nut butter first, then add the jam. This ensures the vibrant jam color peeks out perfectly from the center star cutout.
- Sweet Spreads: Try creamy Nutella, thin slices of banana, or a combination of cream cheese and cinnamon sugar.
- Savory Surprises: These cutouts aren’t just for sweet fillings! Use the larger star cutouts for savory tea sandwiches with fillings like cream cheese and cucumber, or pesto and mozzarella.
Festive Twists
- Seasonal Shapes: Use different cookie cutters for various holidays! Think hearts for Valentine’s Day, pumpkins for Halloween, or circles/squares for simple variety.
- Colored Bread: If you’re making your own bread, try adding food coloring gel to the dough before baking, so your star sammies will be even more fun!
Cutout Star Sandwich Recipe ⭐🥪
Prep time: 10 minutes ⏰
Total time: 20 minutes
Yield: 5 Servings
🍞Ingredients
- 10 slices Soft Sandwich Bread (White or Whole Wheat)
- ¼ cup Jam (or preferred filling like peanut butter or Nutella)
- Optional: Butter or cream cheese (to spread thinly on the bread to prevent sogginess)
⭐Supplies
- Star Cookie Cutters ((One large, one small for the center))
- Table Knife
- Cutting Board
➡️Instructions
- Cut the Base: Use the large star cutter to cut a star shape from all 10 pieces of bread. ✂️
- Cut the Tops: Take 5 of the star-shaped slices and use the small star cutter to cut out the center. These slices will form the sandwich tops.
- Spread the Filling: Spread a small, even amount of jam onto the 5 star slices that do not have a hole. Crucially, do not spread the jam too close to the edges to prevent it from oozing out. 🥄
- Assemble & Press: Place the 5 slices with the star cutout on top of the jam-covered bases. Gently press down to secure the sandwich. 🥪
- Serve & Store: Serve immediately, or store them in an airtight container or wrap tightly in plastic wrap to keep them fresh for later.
Zero Waste Tip: What to Do with Leftover Bread Scraps 🍞
The one downside of using cookie cutters is the pile of leftover bread crusts and scraps—but don’t toss them! Turn these bits into a useful kitchen staple.
Don’t Waste the Edges!
- Homemade Breadcrumbs: The easiest use! Dry the scraps out completely (you can put them in a low oven for 10-15 minutes), then pulse them in a food processor until finely ground. Store them in an airtight container for use in meatballs or casseroles.
- Stuffing/Croutons: Roughly chop the larger pieces and dry them out. They are perfect as bread cubes for holiday stuffing or toss them with oil and seasonings for delicious homemade croutons to top a salad.
- Bread Pudding: If you have a larger quantity of sweet bread scraps, they make a wonderful base for an easy, simple bread pudding.
Ready to Transform Lunch from Boring to Brilliant? ⭐
This easy, kid-friendly method is perfect for getting little ones excited about healthy food.
It proves that lunchtime doesn’t have to be complicated to be fun!
Remember to check out the Customization Station for filling swaps and the Zero Waste Tip for those leftover bread scraps.
More from Mama Likes To Cook
Festive and Fun Christmas Recipes
- Grinch Guacamole
- Peppermint Fudge Truffles
- Chocolate Peppermint Lollipops
- Cutout Star Sandwiches
- Polar Bear Cookies
- Reindeer Cookies
- Reindeer Nutella Sandwiches
- Christmas Cookie Dip
- Christmas Wreath Cheese Platter
- Holiday Hummus Wreath
- Tzatziki Dip Wreath
- Ho Ho Holiday Cherry Mocktail
- Holiday Crock Pot Tea
- Strawberry Swirl Fudge
- Peppermint Sugar
- Reindeer Oreo Pops
Easiest Grape Jam Recipe
- Grape Jam with Just 2 Ingredients
Dip Recipes for Parties
- Pina Colada Fruit Dip
- Garlic Parmesan Chip Dip
- Creamy Jalapeno Dip
- Greek 7 Layer Dip
- Oreo Dessert Dip
Party Appetizers
- Brie & Pear Savory Puff Pastry
- Mexican Dip Snack Cups
- Cherry Cream Cheese Appetizer
- Feta Stuffed Cucumber Appetizer Bites
Holiday Party Punch for The Family
Christmas Cookies
- Mom’s Christmas Sugar Cookies
- Reindeer Oreo Pops
- Chewy Pumpkin Molasses Cookies
- White Chocolate Cherry Pistachio Cookies
- Caramel Apple Cookie Bars
- No Bake Chocolate Cookies
